What does Quadratum look like as a school?
Screen-less Learning.
Comprehensively Self-Sufficiency.
Unabashed Intellectualism.
Irreducibly Rigorous Physical Doings.
Only read this if:
You feel that a child’s scholastic growth does not happen optimally while sitting behind a desk, under fluorescent lights, and looking at a screen displaying an impersonal video with a person who — owing to the medium — cannot take or answer questions. Often these videos are poorly-rendered cartoons.
You feel that formerly inherited, ubiquitous skills — from cooking to light carpentry to house hygiene — no longer transmit infallibly to the next generation and in fact require purchase in the school setting.
You are an educator feeling handcuffed by administrative mandates to deploy superfluous technology; you remain compliant out of fear of reprisal or because a nagging voice tells you that you’re being a stick-in-the-mud forestalling “progress”.
You are a parent watching your child complete schoolwork by making “slideshows” consisting of ready-made clipart and overly-simple sentences intended to encapsulate complex subjects; you note that assessments feel automated, do not remove ignorance of the subject at hand, and allow for re-submission until a high grade is conferred, and that this does not indicate actual accomplishment. It’s not that your child is uniquely more gifted than anyone else. Rather, you feel that students writ-large are not receiving the challenges they merit.
You are a student who wants to explore physicality beyond sports; to musick beyond the level-targeted pieces publishing houses sell to middle school and high school orchestras, bands, and choruses (and you have a suspicion that notation can do more than you’re being shown); to debate intelligently and develop the refined dialogical skillset requisite to convincingly advocate for oneself or others; to take academic risks in order to find out what is worth learning.
You believe students should have meaningful outings that test their academic learning in a practical environment; that students can be responsible for their well-being and live collaboratively; and that taking 6 trips to Mercedes-Benz stadium during middle school may not be the best use of field trip resources. Wish I was kidding.
You are a student that, when it comes to the performance aspect of musics (which is not the sole dimension of music but is presented as if it is), you are tired of being told you’re great, talented, and “superior” when you’re not.
You never want to see or be in another “Junior Musical” the rest of your life, if at all possible. For pete’s sake, folks, they aren’t teaching anything. They are to music education and performance training what McDonald’s Chicken Nuggets are to cuisine. Consider this: students can realize full books (scores and scripts) just fine. So why were these products generated, marketed, and sold so aggressively?
You suspect that students can conceive of, build, and write their own musics, dialogues, rules, sets, fields/pitches of play, timescales, and stakes; and therefore, their own musicals, plays, sports, and, probably, governments.
Something has vanished in education, and while we at Quadratum mean to carve out a singularly focused pedagogical environment, we are aware of what is going on. No one reads anymore. Fine. But we can read, and giving up with a helpless shrug is not a viable option. Reading only the safer excerpts from a work and avoiding its teeth does not fairly represent or respect the work or its creative source. Teaching almost exclusively towards particular scoring metrics on standardized tests limits the generative capacity of young people. Let me put it this way: I don’t want to see my high school freshman doing word searches as part of his high school curriculum. That is neither an exaggeration nor an outlier; other work he does is of a similarly insipid nature.
We are wary of a world where everyone is a high-ability thinker. What room will there be for my riches and powers? How can I distinguish myself and my child as special? But what if we are so stuck in hierarchical rigidity that we cannot envision a most attainable situation where exceptionally-capable individuals also recognize the efficacy of interdependence and act as both humble leaders and eager followers, captains and soldiers, and managers and employees when called to do so.
To be its most effective and its most accessible to all those who value its teachings, Quadratum must be a school. As of now, our students accomplish things beyond what should be possible. Here’s a hyper-granular example: if no other group of local teenagers is capable of harmonized Anglican chant and ours can correctly enact the embodied co-presence of metrical rigor, lexical scope, and vocal production, imagine what they could do with more than two hours a week. In all earnestness, our pedagogical aspirations and students’ capacities lie beyond our current temporal resources. The many worthwhile field trips we take are more difficult logistically than they should be, because we have to do them during weekends and families’ school breaks thereby asking families to sacrifice that precious time together. It is a testament to our students, families, and quality of programming that they do grant us those days and times to go see Mark Warren at Medicine Bow; build out spaces and teach drumming at Murphy-Harpst; and take hikes at Arabia Mountain; &c. We would love to learn from Mark once monthly, but to do that, we would need the weekdays. Beyond this screed, there are mini-treatises below that lay out what ways of thinking undergird our functional policies.
As far as the significant financial investment we require: we need people who need us. We do not merely need money — we need money from people who want what we want: self-reliant young people capable of thinking, creating, and providing for themselves.
-
“Man is not a rational animal; he is a rationalizing animal.” - Robert Heinlein, Assignment in Eternity.
Who knew that book banning could generate such fruitful dialogue? It has helped us clarify what a library’s role is, and how we as a school can form a meaningful curatorial thesis.
Choosing a side on the book ban issue in Marietta, Georgia or anywhere else is unhelpful and unproductive. Books’ inclusion in a library — particularly an academic library — is inevitably a matter of selection and exclusion. It is not principled to have one immovable perspective on this, because libraries do not serve static purposes one school to another. Being principled, then, is to be open-minded. What then are ways to determine inclusion or exclusion from particular sites serving particular student bodies?
Assume that for a moment that, as a fundamental premise, explicit sexual content should be withheld from students until a certain age is met (itself a data-point for debate). Now, let’s move towards a situation where we agree that that age has been met: While the presence of graphic same-sex sexual content in a book may be distasteful, its presence alone is neither a criterion for disqualification or qualification, any more or less than graphic opposite-sex, incestuous, or bestial content would be (see Bible, The).
In terms of such content’s curricular or librarial inclusion, I’m seeing schools deploy a surfeit of excerpts of larger books that may be justified by efficiency arguments, but are we eschewing the discomfiting sections by rationalizing them as inessential? Is it the academic instructor’s right to determine what parts of an author’s book are and are not essential to its teaching. Context matters, but if we are teaching a “book,” it is high-handed to excise parts of it as unnecessary, particularly if that is because it makes us uneasy. Nature sure has beautiful views, don’t it? It’s also deadly. And essentially so. Avoiding that is obviously incomplete education.
To summarize so far: unsavory, uncomfortable, even grotesque content neither justifies nor disqualifies a book’s worthiness. So let’s give our future librarian some guidelines:
Time
Style
Impact
Time
This first criterion protects the second two criteria; that is, duration helpfully rewards lasting impact. Likewise, readers who succumb to being prisoners of the moment may overlook stylistic inadequacies. Therefore, the book must be no less than ten years old in terms of its publication. This avoids recency bias overly affecting the perception of impact. One of the books in question at Marietta High School — Flamer, by Michael Curato — would therefore be moot. In that book’s defense, I have not read it. I don’t know if it was particularly well written or carried impact beyond its cultural shock value. I bristle at the co-presence of instant martyrdom and instant vilification; that may be an unfortunate by-product of the book and not its “fault”, per se. I also find that graphic novels sure are taking up a disproportionate amount of space on the shelves — that’s a personal bias that I would not impose upon an independent librarian. Would it come up during an interview process, though? Yes, it would. Ze would have to convince us, and it would certainly be nice to have a librarian skilled in persuasion and rhetoric.
If the book in question is worth reading, even on the basis of impact alone, then its impact must and should be able to withstand a decade’s passing. If not, and its impact is Zeitgeist-dependent, it is not worth including. If a student has to be told, “at the time, this was actually very incendiary and important,” then that certainly undermines a student’s own ability to perceive, even if they sometimes do need to be told what is worth their time.
Style
This gets into the crux of the matter: quality of writing. This is subjective but only to a point. That is, are the work’s mechanics sound? Are the syntax, grammar, punctuation correct? Those traits can be assessed, whether in a work’s original language or its translation. Then, does the writing convey the meaning of its content efficiently and thoroughly? Is its language vivid as appropriate to the work’s intention? Is that intention itself clear? And, for our purposes, at all relevant? Which takes us to…
Impact
Let’s pretend for a moment that the Bible is not particularly well written. Considering that I do not know anyone who is not reading a translation of the Bible, then I partly mean “well-translated.'“ Regardless, its overwhelmingly outsized impact renders that criterion utterly negligible. Other ways to assess impact include translation. Has the book been translated to English, since we will undoubtedly read it in English? Has it been translated from English? This also speaks to the effectiveness of its writing style. That is, if a style’s effectiveness transcends its vernacular, then that writer (and translator combination) is no doubt potent.
Other factors may inform a particular librarian’s curatorial thesis. I would not include the Harry Potter series — even though it arguably satisfies all of the above criteria — because I believe the content is too focused on entertainment and does not challenge the reader. Here, I am perhaps privileging the need for material that presses upon comfort for inclusion in an academic library.
As for Harry Potter, the other disqualifying aspect would be access. Its ubiquity means that this particular library is not compelled to make it available to students. Less-accessible books take priority.
I recognize that Herman Hesse’s Narziss and Goldmund would probably not be taught in modern public schools, but its inclusion in a library should would be a priority for me. If a teacher wished to include it in a syllabus where its inclusion was relevant to the course writ-large, I would personally not object. And if there was a voice of influence that did object, I would like for the objection to be potent considering that it would satisfy the library’s inclusion criteria. Since this is a live issue, let’s imagine that a book of such high writing quality is objected to.
I’ve a feeling objectors would point to:
An excessively male gaze
A Euro-centric or Euro-derived cultural milieu
Women’s role as fundamentally sexual
and that would be a shame. Because: its lessons are there for all to read; its female characters are often complex and rarely flat even if sexuality is the canvas in which they manifest; and the gaze, while male, is honest and unapologetic; therefore, valuable time is not wasted justifying the content from within the book itself, this creative freedom being a frequent perquisite of late-in-life authorship. And, notwithstanding its obviousness, there are different male gazes at hand. It is possible for the category of “men” to not imply utter homogeneity. Isn’t the un-flattening power of plurality a crucial part of learning, and shouldn’t it in fact be expected in all works of quality?
-
Michael Roth is and has been since September 2007 the President of Wesleyan University in Middletown, Connecticut. He said in a speech to various faculty and students, fairly early in his tenure, that “Wesleyan students tend to read for the flaw, not the point.” It need not be said that President Roth holds Wesleyan students in high regard, and as an alumnus himself, there is undoubtedly in this critique some self-reflection. We like this statement because of its simplicity and because of its prevalence amidst bright, driven, and abetted students. Everyone wants “critical thinkers.” And hopefully, teachers and administrators strive to enact applicable pedagogy and curricula therein.
Regardless of deadlines, we at Quadratum value liberal servings of open air with which to make statements, test theories, and in general to engage in rhetorical risk. These discussions that cover innumerable topics and absolutely veer into touchy categories — political, social, &c. — are among our students’ favorite doings and, in our view, some of the more productive segments of our instruction.
What we most wish to steer them toward is a place of balanced reasoning. The slipperiness of extreme dialectical angles do exactly what they imply: incline quickly towards intractable extreme locations, the so-called echo chambers of contemporary discourse. While a staunch centrism can be seen as avoiding confrontation, we feel that finding ways to appreciate a viewpoint while being able to view it with a disciplined impartiality requires true skill, a psychical and intellectual balancing that may be less glamorous, but may yield longitudinal justice, insight, and growth. Walking a ridgeline is harder than circumnavigating the base of a hill — but you can see more of every side.
Appreciating a presenter’s purpose may be difficult and may even require the experiencer to give the benefit of the doubt over-generously; such intellectual calisthenics, though, are just as skill-fortifying as the ability to dissect and break down an orator’s argument. We hope that by truly weighing costs and benefits of an argument, our students will demonstrate respect to those with whom they are in dialogue while not risk becoming myrmidons to those with excessive charisma or power.
-
Is reading beyond texts and push notifications dead? Is the current state of superficial literacy merely evolution shedding a once-useful but now maladaptive trait? Let’s avoid that existential query by burying our head in some literature, shall we?
A brief futurity of books (severe snark alert in effect)
A “book” could be described or understood as a brick-and-mortar website. Instead of virtual web pages on a site, there are literal “pages” made of paper, access enacted tactilely by hands and finger-touch manipulation as opposed to scanning and clicking or finger-tapping a desired location. This unique delivery mechanism requires innumerable leaves of paper, as opposed to the single impenetrable glass screen that is, let’s admit, the only needed mechanism for all needed information. These paper “pages” are only legible when activated by a separate off-book light source, making book access more difficult outside when natural light wanes. This is why phones are superior sources. Books, having no batteries, cannot be recharged but typically last for centuries if maintained. Eventually, they will yellow unless kept in archival, air-regulated chambers. Book-holders, called “librarians” after some sort of ancient language root, are akin to website admins, or “administrators” – i.e., those who have special access to either the paper “pages” or website data, respectively. To the books:
John Christopher: The White Mountains; The City of Gold and Lead; and The Pool of Fire
Watership Down, by Richard Adams
The Redwall Series, by Brian Jacques
Robert Heinlein: Tunnel in the Sky; Orphans of the Sky; Rocketship Galileo; Red Planet; Have Spacesuit, Will Travel; Starman Jones; Citizen of the Galaxy; The Rolling Stones; Time for the Stars; Farmer of the Sky
L’Engle: A Swiftly Tilting Planet; Many Waters; An Acceptable Time
Le Guin: The Wind’s Twelve Quarters (Short stories); The Earthsea Books; the Annals of the Western Shore books: Gifts, Voices, and Powers; and the trilogy sometimes referred to as the Worlds of Exile and Illusion, which comprise: Rocannon’s World; Planet of Exile; and City of Illusions.
The Invincible, by Stanislaw Lem
A Crown of Feathers (and other stories), by Isaac Bashevis Singer
NB: These books take up endemic situations, problems, opportunities, and optima without the use of sensationalistic or crude language. Nevertheless, there are moments in many of the books that do deal with things of great existential starkness. So it is not graphic content that I am warning about, but rather those hidden, truth-ridden spaces that we consciously and unintentionally avoid.